CEO Fraud: When a Fake Email From the Boss Asks for a Wire Transfer

From the archive: this article was written in 2015 and reflects the technology and threats of that time. For current advice, see our latest articles or ask us directly.

The email arrives on a Tuesday afternoon. It appears to come from the owner of the company, who happens to be out of the office. It is short and a little brusque: a confidential deal is closing, a wire needs to go out today, please handle it quietly and send confirmation when it is done. The bookkeeper, who wants to be helpful and does not want to bother a busy boss, sends the money.

By the time anyone realizes the owner never sent that email, the money has moved through several accounts and is effectively gone. There was no virus, no hacked server and no ransom note. Just a convincing message and a well-meaning employee.

A scam the FBI is warning about

This is often called "CEO fraud." The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) issued a public warning in January about what it calls Business Email Compromise, describing criminals who impersonate executives or trusted suppliers to trick employees into sending wire transfers. The FBI describes losses from these schemes in the hundreds of millions of dollars and notes that businesses of every size are being targeted.

Small businesses are especially appealing targets. There are fewer people involved in approving payments, procedures tend to be informal, and everyone knows everyone, so a request that "sounds like the boss" does not get questioned.

How the scam actually works

These criminals do their homework. Much of what they need is freely available:

  • Who is in charge and who handles money is often right on your website, LinkedIn or a press release.
  • When the boss is traveling can sometimes be learned from social media posts, an out-of-office reply, or simply by calling and asking.
  • How your company writes emails can be learned from any message you have ever sent to anyone.

Then they send the email in one of a few ways:

  • A spoofed address that displays the boss's real email address, even though it did not come from your mail system.
  • A look-alike domain that is off by a letter, such as swapping an "m" for "rn" or adding a hyphen. At a glance, nobody notices.
  • A free email account with the boss's name in the display name, sometimes with an excuse like "sending from my personal account while I am traveling."
  • The real account, if the attacker has managed to steal the owner's email password, often through a phishing email.

The message almost always has the same ingredients: urgency, secrecy, authority, and a reason the boss cannot be reached by phone right now.

The scam does not beat your technology. It beats your process, or the lack of one.

The fix is mostly procedure

Because this is a people problem, the most effective defenses are simple business rules, written down and actually followed.

The call-back rule

Any request to send a wire, change bank details for a vendor, or make an unusual payment gets verified by phone before any money moves. The key detail: you call a number you already have on file, never a number provided in the email. If the email came from a criminal, the phone number in it goes to the criminal too.

Two people for money that leaves

Require a second person to approve wires above a set amount. Most banks can enforce this with dual approval on business online banking. It slows things down by a few minutes, and that is the point.

Give staff permission to say no

This one matters more than it sounds. Owners should tell their team, clearly and in advance, "I will never be upset that you called to confirm a payment request. I will be upset if you do not." Criminals rely on employees being afraid to question the boss.

Treat vendor bank changes with suspicion

A variation of this scam impersonates a supplier asking you to send future payments to a "new account." Verify any change of payment instructions by phone with a known contact.

Technology that helps

Procedures do the heavy lifting, but some technical measures make these emails harder to send and easier to spot:

  • SPF records tell receiving mail servers which servers are allowed to send email for your domain. Combined with DKIM signing, this makes it much harder for someone to spoof your exact address.
  • Business-grade email filtering can flag or quarantine messages that claim to be from your own domain but came from outside, and catch many look-alike domains.
  • An "external email" warning added to the subject or top of messages from outside the company gives staff a visual cue when "the boss" is emailing from somewhere unusual.
  • Strong, unique passwords and two-step verification on email accounts, especially for owners and anyone who handles money. Office 365 and most major email platforms support this.
  • Registering obvious look-alike domains for your business name is inexpensive and removes a few options from the criminal's menu.

What to do this week

  1. Write a one-paragraph payment verification policy and share it with everyone who touches money.
  2. Set up dual approval for wires with your bank.
  3. Have the owner personally tell staff that verification calls are always welcome.
  4. Check that your domain has a valid SPF record.
  5. Turn on two-step verification for email accounts of owners and finance staff.
  6. Ask your IT provider about tagging external emails and filtering spoofed messages.
  7. Know who to call at your bank immediately if a fraudulent wire goes out; speed matters for any chance of recovery.

This scam is growing because it works, and it works because it is cheap to try. A few minutes of procedure and some sensible email settings make your business a lot less attractive. If you would like help tightening up your email security and filtering, take a look at our cybersecurity services or send a note to info@pinellasit.com. We are happy to talk it through.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment