How to Spot a Phishing Email: A Guide for Your Whole Team

From the archive: this article was written in 2021 and reflects the technology and threats of that time. For current advice, see our latest articles or ask us directly.

Most cyberattacks on small businesses don't start with some Hollywood hacker breaking through a firewall. They start with an email. Someone on your team gets a message that looks routine — an invoice, a shipping notice, a note from the boss — clicks a link or opens an attachment, and just like that, the attacker is in.

This is phishing, and it works because it targets people, not computers. The defense isn't a fancy gadget; it's a team that knows what to look for. Print this, share it, and make these red flags second nature for everyone in your office.

Why phishing keeps working

Phishing emails are designed to short-circuit your judgment. They create urgency ("Your account will be closed today!"), lean on authority (a message that appears to come from your CEO or your bank), or dangle curiosity ("See the attached photo"). When you're busy and an email pushes one of those buttons, you act before you think. Attackers know that, and they count on it.

The red flags everyone should know

No single sign proves an email is fake, but the more of these you see, the more suspicious you should be.

  • A sense of urgency or threat. "Act now," "final notice," "your account will be suspended." Pressure to move fast is the most common phishing tactic there is.
  • A mismatched or odd sender address. The display name says "Microsoft," but the actual address is support@micros0ft-secure.com. Always check the real email address, not just the name.
  • Generic greetings. "Dear Customer" or "Dear User" from a company that knows your name is a warning sign.
  • Links that don't match. Hover your mouse over a link (don't click) and look at where it actually goes. If the text says "paypal.com" but the link points somewhere else, stop.
  • Unexpected attachments. Invoices, "voicemails," or "scanned documents" you weren't expecting — especially .zip, .html, or files that ask you to "enable content."
  • Requests for sensitive info. Legitimate companies don't email you asking for your password, full Social Security number, or banking details.
  • Spelling and grammar that feel off. Less common than it used to be, but awkward wording is still a tell.
  • Something just feels wrong. Trust that instinct. If an email is even slightly out of character, treat it as suspicious.

Real-world examples to watch for

These are the patterns we see hit Tampa Bay businesses again and again:

  • The fake invoice. "Please find attached your overdue invoice." It's addressed to accounting, the attachment carries malware, and it's banking on someone in a hurry opening it.
  • The CEO gift-card scam. A new employee gets a text or email "from the owner": "Are you at your desk? I need you to grab some gift cards for a client, I'll reimburse you." It uses authority and urgency together — and it's pure fraud.
  • The Microsoft 365 login trap. "Your password expires today — click here to keep your account active." The link leads to a perfect copy of the Microsoft sign-in page. Type your password and you've handed it straight to the attacker.
  • The delivery notice. "We couldn't deliver your package — confirm your address." A fake tracking link that harvests your information or installs malware.

What to do when you spot one

Make the response simple enough that everyone remembers it under pressure:

  1. Don't click, don't open, don't reply. Not even to argue with the sender.
  2. Verify through a separate channel. If "the boss" or "the bank" is asking for something, call them on a number you already know — not one from the email.
  3. Report it. Forward it to whoever handles your IT, or use your email program's "report phishing" button. Reporting helps protect the rest of the team, too.
  4. If you already clicked, speak up immediately. Mistakes happen. The worst thing an employee can do is stay quiet out of embarrassment while the clock is ticking. Fast reporting can be the difference between a near-miss and a full breach.
Build a culture where reporting a mistake is rewarded, not punished. The team that feels safe saying "I think I messed up" is the team that stops a small problem from becoming a disaster.

Make the inbox itself harder to spoof

Training your people is half the battle. The other half is making it harder for attackers to convincingly impersonate your domain in the first place. Email authentication standards called SPF, DKIM, and DMARC tell the world which servers are allowed to send mail as your business — and help block forgeries before they ever reach an inbox.

Not sure whether your domain is protected? Checking your SPF and DMARC records is a quick way to find a gap most small businesses don't know they have. If you're not sure how to read them — or whether they're set up correctly — our team can review your domain and tell you in plain English whether you're covered. It's part of how we approach email security for the businesses we support.

The bottom line

Phishing succeeds when people are rushed, distracted, or unaware. A team that knows the red flags, pauses before clicking, and reports anything fishy is a genuinely hard target — no expensive software required. Pair that awareness with strong email authentication and the layered defenses we cover in our cybersecurity approach, and you've shut down the path attackers use most.

If you'd like help training your team or locking down your email, we work with businesses across Pinellas and Pasco County to do exactly that. Sometimes the smartest security investment is the one that costs nothing but a little attention.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment