Slack, Microsoft Teams, or Just Email? Choosing Team Chat for a Small Office

From the archive: this article was written in 2016 and reflects the technology and threats of that time. For current advice, see our latest articles or ask us directly.

On November 2, Microsoft announced Microsoft Teams, a chat-based workspace built into Office 365. It's in preview now for business customers, with general availability promised for the first quarter of 2017. The same day, Slack ran a full-page ad in The New York Times welcoming Microsoft to the market, in a tone that was equal parts friendly and pointed. The team chat wars are officially on.

For a small business, the interesting part isn't the rivalry. It's that group chat, which a couple of years ago felt like something only software startups did, is becoming a normal way for offices to work. So should yours? And if so, which one? Here's a practical look.

What team chat is good for

Team chat tools organize conversations into channels, usually by project, department, or topic, instead of long email threads. Anyone in the channel can see the discussion, search it later, and jump in. You can also send direct messages, share files, and connect other services so alerts show up in the conversation.

Where it really shines:

  • Quick back-and-forth that would otherwise be a dozen short emails.
  • Teams that aren't in the same room, like staff split across two locations, or people who work from home or in the field.
  • Keeping new people in the loop. Someone who joins a project can scroll back through the channel instead of being forwarded a pile of emails.
  • Cutting down internal email, which leaves the inbox for customers and vendors.

Slack: the one everyone's talking about

Slack has grown very quickly and set the standard for what team chat should feel like. It's polished, fast, and easy to learn. It connects to a huge number of other services, from Google Drive and Dropbox to project management tools.

Slack has a free plan that works for small teams, though it limits how far back you can search, plus paid plans priced per user that add full history, more storage, and more administrative control. If your business isn't built around Microsoft, or you're already on G Suite (formerly Google Apps), Slack is an easy fit.

The tradeoff: it's one more separate service with its own logins, its own file storage, and its own bill. Your files end up split between Slack and wherever else you keep documents.

Microsoft Teams: the one you may already own

Teams' biggest selling point is where it lives. It's being included with the Office 365 business and enterprise plans many small businesses already pay for, such as Business Essentials and Business Premium, with no additional cost announced. Each team is connected to Office 365 behind the scenes: files are stored in SharePoint, meetings and calls connect to Skype for Business, and notes can live in OneNote. Users sign in with the same accounts they use for email.

That integration is appealing for an office that already runs on Outlook, Word, and Excel. The caution: Teams is brand new and still in preview. Features will change before release, and it's reasonable to expect some rough edges. It's a fine time to try it with a small group, not the moment to move the whole company over.

If you already pay for Office 365, try Teams before you pay for something else. If you don't, Slack is the more mature product today.

When plain email is still the right answer

Chat isn't a replacement for everything, and some offices will be perfectly happy without it. Email is still better for:

  • Anything involving people outside the company: customers, vendors, your accountant.
  • Formal decisions and records that need a clear paper trail.
  • Longer, thoughtful messages that aren't meant for immediate response.

For a five-person office where everyone sits within earshot, chat may add more noise than value. For a twenty-person business split between a Largo office and a New Port Richey warehouse, it can be a genuine improvement.

Governance: a few ground rules before you start

Chat tools are easy to adopt, which is exactly why they can get messy. A little planning up front avoids problems later:

  • Pick one tool. The worst outcome is half the office on Slack, a quarter on Teams, and the rest texting. Decide, and make it official.
  • Company accounts only. Staff should sign in with company-managed accounts so access can be removed when someone leaves.
  • Decide what doesn't belong in chat. Passwords, customer credit card numbers, and sensitive personal information shouldn't be pasted into a channel. If you're in a regulated field like healthcare, check how the tool handles compliance requirements before using it for anything involving patient data.
  • Think about retention. How long are messages kept? Can you search or export them if you need to for a dispute or legal request?
  • Watch the add-ons. Connecting outside apps is powerful, but each one gets access to some of your data. An administrator should approve them.
  • Set expectations about response time. Chat can create pressure to answer instantly. Make it clear that "online" doesn't mean "available" at all hours.

A simple way to decide

  1. Ask whether internal email is actually a pain point. If not, you may not need chat yet.
  2. If you're on Office 365, sign a small group up for the Teams preview.
  3. If you're not, run a free Slack trial with the same small group.
  4. Use it for real work for a month, then ask the group honestly whether it helped.
  5. Write down your ground rules before rolling it out to everyone.
  6. Revisit Teams when it reaches general availability next year.

The bottom line

Team chat is here to stay, and Microsoft's entry means most small businesses will have a version of it included in what they already pay for. There's no rush, but there's also no reason not to try it. If you'd like help turning on Teams in your Office 365 account, or figuring out which plan fits your office, our cloud solutions team can help. Reach us at info@pinellasit.com.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment