Moving Beyond Tape: Disk-Based and Offsite Backup for Small Business

From the archive: this article was written in 2010 and reflects the technology and threats of that time. For current advice, see our latest articles or ask us directly.

In a lot of small offices there's a ritual that goes something like this: at the end of the day, someone pops a tape out of the server, puts in the next one from a labeled box, and maybe takes Friday's tape home. It has been that way for years. Nobody really thinks about it until the day they need to restore a file, and discover that the tape drive has been reporting errors since spring.

Tape served businesses well for a long time. But for most small businesses it's become the weakest link in their data protection, and the alternatives have gotten cheaper and better. Here's why it's time to move on, and what to move to.

The trouble with tape

Tape isn't inherently bad. Large data centers still use it for long-term archiving, with dedicated staff and expensive robotic libraries. The problem is how tape works in a typical small office:

  • It depends on a person. Someone has to swap the tape, every day. Vacations, sick days, and busy seasons all create gaps.
  • Tapes wear out. Media reused night after night degrades, and drive heads need cleaning. Florida humidity doesn't help, especially for tapes stored in a hot car or a damp garage.
  • Failures are quiet. Backup jobs fail or skip files, and unless someone is reading the logs, nobody knows.
  • Restores are slow. Finding one file can mean locating the right tape, loading it, and waiting while the drive winds through it. Restoring an entire server can take a very long time.
  • Data outgrew the tapes. As files get bigger, backups no longer fit on one tape, and the whole process gets more complicated.
The question isn't "do we have a backup?" It's "when did we last successfully restore from it?"

Disk-based backup: faster and simpler

Hard drives have become remarkably cheap, and that has changed the backup equation. Instead of writing to tape, the server backs up to disk, whether a dedicated backup device, a network storage box (NAS), or external drives. The benefits are immediate:

  • Speed. Backups finish faster, and restoring a single file takes seconds instead of a scavenger hunt.
  • Reliability. Disk is random-access, so there's no winding through tape, and failures are easier to detect.
  • Automation. Backups run on a schedule with no one swapping anything.
  • Image-based backup. Many modern backup programs capture the whole server, including Windows, applications, and settings, not just the files. If the server dies, you can restore the entire system to new hardware far faster than reinstalling everything from scratch. Windows Server 2008 even includes its own disk-based backup tool.

There's one catch: a backup device sitting next to the server shares its fate. Fire, flood, theft, a lightning strike, or a hurricane that takes out the server will take out the backup too. That's why disk-based backup is only half the answer.

Offsite and online backup: the other half

A good backup plan keeps at least one copy of your data away from your office. There are two main ways to do it:

Rotating drives

Backups go to external drives, and one is regularly taken offsite. It's inexpensive and it works, but it has the same weakness as tape: it depends on a person remembering, every time, and on the drive being stored somewhere safer than the office.

Online backup

Your data is encrypted and sent over the internet to a secure data center, automatically, usually every night. After the first full copy, only the changes are sent, so the nightly traffic is manageable even on an ordinary business internet connection. No one has to remember anything, and your data is safe even if your whole building isn't. For businesses along the Gulf coast, that alone is a strong argument, as we covered in our hurricane season checklist.

The best setups combine both: fast local disk backup for everyday restores, plus an automatic online copy for disasters. That combination is often called disk-to-disk-to-offsite, and it's quickly becoming the standard for small businesses.

Testing restores: the step everyone skips

Here's an uncomfortable truth: a backup that has never been restored is an unproven backup. Backup software can report "success" while quietly skipping open files, missing a database that changed locations, or leaving out a folder someone created last year. The only way to know is to test.

  • Restore a few random files every month and make sure they open.
  • Restore critical databases, like accounting or practice management data, to a test location and make sure the application can read them.
  • At least once a year, rehearse a full recovery. How long would it take to get the server back? Is that acceptable for your business?
  • Have someone review backup reports daily, or better, have your backup system monitored so failures get noticed and fixed right away.

Making the switch

  1. List what needs protecting: servers, databases, email, and any important data living on individual PCs or laptops.
  2. Decide how much you can afford to lose (a day's work? an hour's?) and how quickly you need to be back up.
  3. Set up local disk-based backup, ideally image-based, for fast restores.
  4. Add an automatic offsite copy, online or rotated drives.
  5. Keep the old tapes and at least one working drive that can read them until you're sure you no longer need that older data.
  6. Test a restore before calling the project finished, and schedule regular tests after that.

The bottom line

Tape did its job for a long time, but for a small business it's become slow, fragile, and too dependent on someone remembering a daily chore. Disk-based backup paired with an automatic offsite copy is faster, more reliable, and far more likely to actually save you when something goes wrong. If you'd like help retiring the tape drive and building a backup plan you can trust, take a look at our backup and disaster recovery services or drop us a line at info@pinellasit.com.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment