Sticky Notes, Spreadsheets, and a Better Way: Password Managers for Business

From the archive: this article was written in 2014 and reflects the technology and threats of that time. For current advice, see our latest articles or ask us directly.

Walk through almost any small office and you will find them. A sticky note on the monitor. An index card in the top drawer labeled "logins." A spreadsheet on the shared drive called something like passwords_FINAL.xls. None of these people are careless. They are simply trying to keep track of dozens of accounts with the tools at hand.

The Heartbleed scramble in April made the scale of the problem obvious. People sat down to change their passwords and realized they had no idea how many accounts they had, or which ones shared the same password. There is a better way, and it is neither expensive nor complicated: a password manager.

The real problem is reuse

Most people know a good password should be long and hard to guess. The trouble is that humans cannot remember forty long, unique passwords. So we compromise. We use one strong password everywhere, or a base word with a number that changes. That feels reasonable until one site gets breached.

When a website is compromised, attackers often take the list of email addresses and passwords and try them everywhere else — email, banking, social media, business services. If you reused that password, one breach at a site you barely remember becomes access to your business email. We have watched this play out across the news this year with one large breach after another.

The strongest password in the world is only as strong as the weakest site you also used it on.

What a password manager does

A password manager is an encrypted vault for your logins. You remember one strong master password. The manager remembers everything else. Most of them will:

  • Generate long, random, unique passwords for every account.
  • Fill them in automatically when you visit the site, so you never type them.
  • Sync across your computers and phone.
  • Store other sensitive notes: software license keys, Wi-Fi passwords, alarm codes.
  • Warn you about weak or duplicate passwords already in your vault.

The autofill feature has a nice security bonus. A password manager fills in your bank password only on your bank's real website. If a phishing email sends you to a convincing fake, the manager will not recognize the address and will not offer your password — a useful warning sign.

Popular options include LastPass, 1Password, Dashlane, and KeePass. They differ in price, whether your vault lives in the cloud or on your own computer, and how well they handle teams. There is no single right answer, but any of the well-known ones is a huge step up from a spreadsheet.

Why not just a spreadsheet?

A spreadsheet of passwords is not encrypted in any meaningful way. Anyone who gets into that shared folder — a disgruntled former employee, a virus, a thief with a stolen laptop — gets every login at once. Spreadsheets also get copied, emailed, and printed. And when an employee leaves, nobody really knows which passwords they saw.

Sticky notes have the same problem in physical form, plus the cleaning crew and every visitor who walks past the desk.

Shared vaults for teams

Businesses have a need that individuals do not: several people legitimately need the same login. The office manager and the owner both need the bank. Three people post to the company Facebook page. Everyone needs the Wi-Fi password.

Business editions of password managers handle this with shared folders or vaults. Instead of emailing a password around, you share an entry with specific people. Some tools let you share a login without revealing the actual password, so staff can sign in but cannot write it down. When someone leaves, you remove their access in one place and know exactly which passwords to change.

A sensible structure for a small office might be:

  • A personal vault for each employee's own accounts.
  • A shared office folder for common logins such as vendor portals and the Wi-Fi.
  • A restricted folder for banking, payroll, and administrator credentials, shared only with the people who need them.

Protect the master password

The obvious objection: "Isn't it risky to put every password in one place?" It is a fair question. The answer is that the vault is encrypted, and a well-designed manager never stores your master password in a form it can read. That puts all the weight on two things.

First, make the master password strong. A passphrase of several unrelated words is long, hard to guess, and still memorable. Never use it anywhere else.

Second, turn on two-step verification. Most managers support it. After your password, you enter a code from an app on your phone or a small hardware key. Even if someone learns your master password, they cannot open the vault without that second step. While you are at it, turn on two-step verification for your email, which is the key to resetting everything else.

Getting started

  1. Pick one password manager for the business so everyone uses the same tool.
  2. Set up the owner or office manager first, with a strong master password and two-step verification.
  3. Start with the most important accounts: email, banking, payroll, and anything holding customer data.
  4. Change reused passwords to unique, generated ones as you add them.
  5. Create shared folders for team logins and retire the spreadsheet.
  6. Shred the sticky notes. Really.
  7. Write down how to recover access if the master password is forgotten, and store that somewhere safe.

Moving a team to a password manager takes an afternoon of setup and a week or two of new habits. After that, most people wonder how they managed without it. If you would like help choosing a tool, setting up shared vaults, or rolling it out to your staff, it is part of the cybersecurity work we do for businesses across Pinellas and Pasco. Send us a note at info@pinellasit.com.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment