When Hackers Call the Help Desk: Stopping Password Reset Scams

The call sounds completely routine. An employee is traveling, got a new phone, and can no longer get into their account. They are polite, a little stressed, and they know their manager's name and their own employee ID. Could the help desk please reset their password and re-register their multi-factor authentication?

That call is one of the most effective hacking techniques in use today. It is how some of the most damaging attacks of the past two years began, and it is back in the news as a wave of attacks hits major retailers in the United Kingdom. The good news: it is also one of the most preventable, if you set up the right process.

What is happening in the U.K.

In late April, Marks & Spencer, one of Britain's best-known retailers, was hit by a cyberattack that forced it to suspend online orders and disrupted parts of its business. Other U.K. retailers, including the Co-op, have also reported attacks in the days since. Details are still emerging, but widely circulated reporting has pointed to social engineering as part of how the attackers got in, and security researchers have linked the activity to the loose group of attackers known as Scattered Spider, or to people using the same playbook.

If that name sounds familiar, it should. We wrote about the 2023 attacks on Las Vegas casinos, which were widely reported to have started with a phone call to a help desk. The technique has not changed because it keeps working.

How the scam works

The attacker's goal is simple: get the help desk to hand over control of a real employee's account. A typical attempt looks like this:

  1. Research. The attacker gathers names, job titles, and reporting lines from LinkedIn, the company website, and previous data breaches. Sometimes they have already stolen a password and just need to get past MFA.
  2. The call. They phone the help desk posing as the employee, often claiming a lost or new phone. They may spoof caller ID and sound confident and fluent in the company's jargon.
  3. Pressure. They are in a hurry. A client meeting is starting, the boss is waiting, they are about to board a flight.
  4. The reset. A helpful technician resets the password and registers the attacker's phone as the new MFA device.
  5. The takeover. With a working login and MFA under their control, the attacker is now, as far as your systems are concerned, a legitimate employee.

Notice what is missing: no malware, no clever exploit. Just a person being helpful, which is exactly what we train help desk staff to be.

Multi-factor authentication protects the login. It does not protect the process for resetting multi-factor authentication. That process needs its own lock.

Why small businesses are exposed too

It is tempting to think this only matters for giant companies with call centers. In a small office, the "help desk" might be the office manager, a tech-savvy employee, or an outside IT provider. That can actually make things easier for an attacker: fewer formal procedures, more familiarity, and a stronger instinct to just help. A caller who says "Hi, it's Mike from the Clearwater office, I got locked out" may be waved through by someone who does not want to seem difficult.

Building a verification process that holds up

The fix is a written procedure for password and MFA resets that everyone follows every time, no matter who is calling or how urgent it sounds. Good procedures share a few features:

  • Never trust caller ID. It can be faked easily. If a request comes in by phone, hang up and call the employee back at the number already on file, not a number the caller gives you.
  • Do not rely on information an attacker can find. Names, birthdays, employee IDs, and the last four digits of a Social Security number are all easy to research or buy. They are not proof of identity.
  • Get confirmation from a second person. For MFA resets especially, require the employee's manager to confirm the request through a separate channel.
  • Use video verification when possible. A quick video call where the person shows their face alongside a photo ID is much harder to fake than a voice on the phone, though not impossible as deepfakes improve.
  • Consider in-person resets for MFA. For a small office, requiring someone to come in, or to have a manager verify them face to face, is often perfectly practical.
  • Give the help desk permission to say no. Make it clear, from leadership, that following the process is never the wrong answer, even if the caller claims to be the CEO.

Technical safeguards that help

Process is the main defense, but technology can back it up:

  • Alert on MFA changes. Have your systems notify the user and IT whenever a new MFA method is registered. A real employee will speak up fast if it was not them.
  • Use phishing-resistant MFA like passkeys or security keys for administrators and finance staff, which are harder to reassign remotely.
  • Limit who can reset admin accounts. Resets for privileged accounts should require extra approval.
  • Watch for unusual sign-ins right after a reset, such as logins from new locations or devices.

What to do this week

  1. Write down your password and MFA reset procedure, or ask your IT provider for theirs.
  2. Require callback to a number on file for every phone-based reset request.
  3. Add manager confirmation for MFA device changes.
  4. Turn on alerts for new MFA registrations and password resets.
  5. Tell your staff, from the top, that following the process is always the right call.
  6. Run a quick test: have someone call in with a plausible story and see what happens.

Helpful, but not too helpful

Your help desk exists to get people back to work quickly, and that is a good thing. The goal is not to make every reset painful. It is to make sure a friendly voice on the phone is not enough to hand over the keys. Verification procedures are built into how we run support in our managed IT services, and we are happy to help you set up your own. Email info@pinellasit.com or reach out through our contact form.

Need help with this?

Talk to a local IT team that has supported businesses across Pinellas & Pasco County since 2010.

Get a Free Consultation Free Security Assessment