Email has run on the honor system for decades. When a message says it is from your company, the receiving server has historically taken that more or less on faith. Scammers have exploited that trust for just as long, sending invoices, password resets, and wire requests that appear to come from domains they do not own.
Last October, Google and Yahoo announced they were done with the honor system. Beginning in February 2024, both are phasing in requirements for anyone sending mail to Gmail and Yahoo addresses, with the strictest rules aimed at bulk senders. Even if your business never sends a newsletter, this is a good moment to get your domain's email authentication in order. It takes an afternoon, and it closes a door criminals have been walking through for years.
What exactly is changing
The new rules come in two tiers. For everyone sending to Gmail or Yahoo accounts, the expectations are basic hygiene:
- Authenticate your mail with SPF or DKIM.
- Have valid DNS records for your sending servers.
- Keep your reported spam rate low (Google has said to stay below 0.3%).
- Send over an encrypted (TLS) connection.
For bulk senders, which Google defines as sending roughly 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail addresses, the bar is higher:
- Both SPF and DKIM, plus a published DMARC record.
- The "From" address has to line up (align) with the domain that passed SPF or DKIM.
- Marketing and subscription messages need a one-click unsubscribe option, and unsubscribe requests have to be honored within two days.
Google has said enforcement will ramp up gradually through the year rather than flip a switch overnight, with the one-click unsubscribe requirement coming a bit later. But mail that does not meet the rules will increasingly be delayed, sent to spam, or rejected outright.
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC in plain English
These three acronyms sound intimidating, but each one answers a simple question.
SPF: who is allowed to send for us?
SPF (Sender Policy Framework) is a DNS record that lists the servers permitted to send mail for your domain: your email provider, your marketing platform, your billing system, and so on. A receiving server checks the list. If the message came from a server that is not on it, that is a red flag.
DKIM: was this message really signed by us?
DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) adds a digital signature to every outgoing message. The matching public key lives in your DNS. If the signature checks out, the receiver knows the message came from an authorized system and was not altered along the way.
DMARC: what should happen when a check fails?
DMARC ties the other two together. It tells receiving servers what to do with mail that claims to be from your domain but fails authentication, whether that is nothing (monitor only), send it to spam, or reject it. Just as useful, DMARC sends you reports showing who is sending email using your domain name. The first time most businesses read those reports, they find at least one service they forgot about, and occasionally a stranger they never authorized.
SPF lists who may send. DKIM proves a message is genuine. DMARC tells the world what to do with the fakes.
Why this matters even if you are not a "bulk sender"
Most small businesses in Tampa Bay will never come close to 5,000 messages a day. So why bother?
First, deliverability. Mail from domains without authentication is simply treated with more suspicion. Quotes, invoices, and appointment reminders landing in a customer's spam folder cost you real money, and you usually never find out it happened.
Second, spoofing. Without DMARC enforcement, anyone can send a message that shows your exact domain in the "From" line. That is the raw material for fake invoices sent to your customers and fake "CEO" requests sent to your own bookkeeper. A DMARC policy set to quarantine or reject tells Gmail, Yahoo, Microsoft, and most other major providers to stop those messages before they reach anyone's inbox.
Third, the rest of the industry is heading the same way. Google and Yahoo are the ones making headlines, but authentication is quickly becoming the price of admission for reliable email everywhere.
The common snags we run into
Setting up these records is not hard, but there are a few traps that trip up a typical small office:
- Forgotten senders. Your accounting software, your website contact form, your copier's scan-to-email, and your CRM may all send mail "as" your domain. Each one needs to be included in SPF or set up with DKIM, or its messages will start failing.
- Too many SPF lookups. SPF has a limit of ten DNS lookups. Stack enough services into one record and it quietly breaks.
- Two SPF records. A domain can only have one. Adding a second one instead of editing the first is a very common mistake.
- Jumping straight to "reject." Turning on a strict DMARC policy before you know every legitimate sender can block your own mail. Start in monitoring mode, read the reports, then tighten.
- Unused domains. Old or parked domains you own can be spoofed too. They should have records that say, in effect, "this domain sends no mail."
What to do now
- Inventory every service that sends email as your domain. Ask each department; you will likely be surprised.
- Publish or clean up your SPF record so it lists all of them in a single record, within the lookup limit.
- Turn on DKIM signing in Office 365 or Google Workspace, and in any marketing or billing platform that supports it.
- Publish a DMARC record at p=none with a reporting address, and review the reports for a few weeks.
- Move to quarantine, then reject once you are confident legitimate mail is passing.
- If you send newsletters or promotions, confirm your email platform supports one-click unsubscribe and that it is switched on.
Worth doing right
This is one of those rare security improvements that also makes your day-to-day business run better: more of your mail gets delivered, and fewer scammers can pretend to be you. It is a core part of the email protection we set up as part of our cybersecurity services. If you would like someone to check your domain's records and read those DMARC reports with you, email us at info@pinellasit.com or reach out through our contact form.
